Apple has answered Epic Games' claim that it improperly held back more than 122,000 documents in the dispute over the commission it plans to charge on link-out purchases, according to 9to5Mac, which reviewed the company's latest court filing.
What Epic wants
Epic argues that the documents matched agreed search terms drawn from the records of seven initial custodians, and it wants the court to order Apple to produce everything that matches and is not privileged, regardless of Apple's own judgment about relevance. Epic proposed a December 2 deadline, which Apple says it cannot meet. Epic's 16 requested categories include internal analyses of the financial impact of the proposed commissions and communications about strategies to discourage developers from offering link-outs.
Apple's argument
In its filing, Apple describes Epic's search terms as overbroad rather than tailored. It gives two examples: the term "commission*" also catches government and private commissions and references to commissioners, while "fee*" matches unrelated words such as "feel" and "feedback."
Apple also says at least 95 percent of the documents hit in the initial custodian set matched only generic terms and never mention link-outs. According to the filing, as summarized by 9to5Mac, those hits included personal tax and medical records, unannounced product material, documents containing passwords, investor-relations files and privileged legal communications.
Apple's legal position is that parties must produce responsive documents, not everything a search string returns. It calls Epic's requested remedy "extraordinary and unprecedented." Reviewing, redacting and logging privilege over that volume, Apple says, makes the December 2 date impossible.
Alternative Apple proposes
Apple asks the court to reject Epic's motion. If the court decides some intervention is warranted, Apple suggests that a randomized, statistically significant sample of the documents it deemed nonresponsive go to a Special Master for independent review, rather than being handed to Epic wholesale.
Background
The fight over documents sits within the wider dispute over what Apple may charge on purchases made outside the App Store in the U.S. Apple told the district court in August that it was proposing commissions of 5 to 15 percent on such purchases. Separately, the Supreme Court is expected to consider whether to uphold the civil contempt finding against Apple, and Epic has urged it to do so.
The article does not name the judge or a hearing date, and 9to5Mac's piece does not say when Apple filed its brief. The court has not ruled on Epic's motion as of this report.

0 comments