The Investigatory Powers Tribunal has ruled that the UK government cannot keep secret whether it ordered Apple to weaken the encryption protecting customer data, according to a Financial Times report relayed by MacRumors on Thursday.

The tribunal found that the government had not demonstrated that confirming the demand would harm national security. It said the Home Office must acknowledge that it served Apple with a technical capability notice, a type of order that can compel a company to provide access to encrypted data. According to the report, the tribunal noted that officials had already spoken about the matter to journalists and to US officials, which went well beyond the government's usual policy of neither confirming nor denying such orders, and it described the national security argument as "fanciful".

What happens next

The decision is about secrecy, not about whether the demands are lawful. That question remains undecided. But because the government can no longer rely on blanket confidentiality, much of Apple's challenge, along with a separate case brought by Privacy International and Liberty, can now proceed largely in open court. MacRumors says the Privacy International hearing on the substance is listed for December 2026.

Background

Apple filed its latest challenge in July 2026 over a second technical capability notice. The Home Office had earlier withdrawn a demand that covered both UK and US users. Apple stopped offering Advanced Data Protection, its end-to-end encryption option for iCloud, to new UK users in February 2025, and has said it cannot switch the feature off for people who have already enabled it.

MacRumors reports that neither Apple nor the government gave a new statement about this particular ruling. We will update this story if either side comments or if the tribunal publishes further detail on how the open hearings will proceed.

0 comments

Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.